Okay, so both products are the same price at £4.99 (which I think is a really good price), however with the L'Oreal Paris version, you only get 200ml whereas with Garnier you get double at 400ml. This makes a huge difference in preference for me, why buy half the amount for the same price? Who knows. Both claim to have this 3 step process - removing make-up, cleansing and thirdly, smoothing skin. I do think that both products do this pretty well. They both remove my make-up really well including eye make-up. I've heard they're not very good with waterproof eye make-up but then I don't really wear waterproof so it doesn't affect me. I've also noticed that since using both of these, I break out a LOT less. That may just be because I'm looking after my skin more though. The only negative comment I have, is that I can't use the L'Oreal water on my eyes, but I can use the Garnier - no idea why this is as both products have practically the same ingredients.
The one downside to both of these products is the amount of product wasted. Both have a hole tops and the amount of product that comes out sooo quickly is annoying. Obviously the solution it to place a cotton pad over the opening and let it soak into it - but it's still annoying. I got through the L'Oreal seriously quickly as it's only 200ml but Garnier has lasted me a lot longer.
After using both, I can say that I'll be re-purchasing the Garnier version for the pure fact that you get double to the product for the same amount of money.
Have you used either of these products?
- Charli, xo